So, I’ve been grinding away at MLB The Show lately, and man, those quicksell values can be a real head-scratcher. Figured I’d share my experiences and what I’ve learned so far.
First off, I started by diving headfirst into Diamond Dynasty. I pulled a bunch of packs, some from codes, some from just playing the game, and I gotta say, it felt good to open those up. I was thinking, what should I do with the extra cards?

Then I realized, hey, I need to check these quicksell values. I remember seeing something about it online. I went to check the quicksell values in the game. I found out that they ain’t all the same. Some of the cards that I thought were gonna be worth a bunch were just sitting there with low values. It is really confusing.
So, I started to dig a little deeper. I spent hours comparing cards, trying to figure out the logic behind it all. Here’s what I found:
- Bronze cards: These are your common everyday cards. Quicksell values range from like 5 to 25 stubs. Not much, but they can add up if you’ve got a ton.
- Silver cards: These guys start to get a bit more interesting. I saw values anywhere from 25 to 100 stubs. It is important to note that.
- Gold cards: Now we’re talking. Gold cards can fetch you a decent amount, from around 100 to 1000 stubs. I was stoked when I pulled some good golds.
- Diamond cards: These are the big boys. But here’s where it gets tricky. The values can range from 1000 all the way up to 5000 stubs. Some of the same OVR diamond cards got different quick sell values, it is really confusing.
I spent a good chunk of time just comparing the values, doing the math, and figuring out which cards were worth keeping for collections and which ones I should just quicksell. My eyes were all tired after that.
In the end, I managed to make a decent amount of stubs by quickselling the cards I didn’t need. It wasn’t a fortune, but it was enough to get me a few new players for my Diamond Dynasty team.
And that’s my story about quicksell values in MLB The Show. It’s a bit of a grind, but hey, it’s all part of the game, right?