Okay, so I wanted to mess around with the catcher signs in MLB The Show 24. I’d seen some cool custom setups online, and figured, “Why not give it a shot?”
First, I jumped into the game and headed over to the settings. I spent a good few minutes just poking around, trying to find where the heck this option was. It’s not exactly labeled “Catcher Signs” or anything obvious, you know?

Customization Options
Eventually, I stumbled upon it under the presentation or gameplay settings – can’t remember exactly which, to be honest. It was buried in there! Once I found it, though, it was pretty straightforward.
- I could choose from a bunch of preset sign sequences. Some were simple, some were more elaborate.
- I could even customize the individual signs – like, what gesture meant fastball, curveball, etc. It’s pretty detailed!
I started by picking a preset that looked kinda cool, something a little more animated than the default. Then I tweaked it a bit. I swapped a couple of signs around to make them feel more natural to me, based on how I remember catchers doing it in real life (from my couch, of course).
After saving my changes, I hopped into a quick exhibition game to see how it looked. It was definitely different! It took a little getting used to, seeing my custom signs play out on the screen. But after a few innings, it felt pretty slick.
Honestly, It’s not a game-changer or anything, but it’s a fun little detail to personalize. If you’re into the nitty-gritty of baseball, messing with the catcher signs in MLB The Show 24 is worth checking out. Just be prepared to do some digging in the menus to find it!